Wow! I've been on holiday soaking up the sun for the last few days, and return not only to find this War and Peace epic, but also clarification from VAA direct in response to the strong views that have been expressed on the site - it's as good as Coronation Street! Actually, since I haven't watched Coronation Street for 15 years or so it must be even better:D
I'll be fascinated to see how this service turns out next month, but I do have mixed feelings at present: When travelling on business I would welcome a calm and quiet cabin earlier than the current regime allows, especially on east coast flights. But enforced lights-out after an hour, especially on longer journeys or when I'm travelling on leisure does seem a recipe for problems. Trying to eat a full meal when relying on a reading light, and guilt pangs about keeping someone in the next seat awake, both seem pretty negative. With that said, I'm willing to give it a go and see what the reaction is. If it works, and business-sleepers can co-exist comfortably with party-animals heading off on their hols, then this might prove pretty good.
I've got no UC travel coming up before the end of the year on current plans, so I hope the service will either be well bedded-in, or scrapped, by the time I get to try it.
Best wishes
David